It’s All A Conspiracy
In 1947, a strange object was seen flying across the sky above Roswell, New Mexico. It filled the night sky with a sharp white light and then disappeared. A few farmers found mangled metal strewn across their fields and took the debris to the local authorities. The government immediately stated that the metal was from a weather balloon that was lost earlier in the week, but confiscated the debris for ‘further testing’.
And thus, Area 51 was born: a small government facility in the desert of southern Nevada dedicated solely to investigating aliens. Or so some think. If that’s true, it’s one of the worst-kept secrets in history.
But today, conspiracy theories–from aliens to assassinations to Apollo 11–have become a well-loved aspect of American culture. History teacher Brett Melton says, “They have become a little more prevalent in society than I would want them to be. Conspiracy theories usually change from decade to decade and they can reflect the public’s distrust in the government.”
Apple Valley English teacher Dr. Bob Helgeson offers his opinion on our culture’s view of these theories: “Often, the only thing that separates a so-called ‘conspiracy’ theory from a consideration as a more ‘valid’ theory is a person’s values, beliefs, or biases, rather than an accumulation of actual evidence.”
So today, let’s take a closer look at some of America’s favorites, with the help of one of Apple Valley’s own historians, Mr. Brett Melton:
9/11 cover-up
Walking the halls of Apple Valley every once in awhile I’ll hear someone say “Bush did 9/11” and it gets me wondering. The Week magazine wrote in 2011 that there are ten separate conspiracy theories surrounding 9/11 and “who did it?”
Melton says that the most outlandish out of all 9/11 cover ups is the idea that the United States had something to do with it. “There were over 3, 000 deaths in the attack; there’s no way that could be beneficial to the US government.”
But unlike Mr. Melton, members of the Apple Valley Debate team, who want to remain anonymous, stand strongly by the fact that Bush was behind 9/11. Their main argument is, “jet fuel can’t melt steel beams.”
JFK Assassination
Many of us have seen the strange parallels between Abraham Lincoln and John Fitzgerald Kennedy, but the strangest theory surrounding JFK is his assassination. Charles Shaffer Jr., who served as a Justice Department prosecutor in 1964, was one of the men in charge of investigating the assassination.
In an interview in 2014, Shaffer said that there were more developments to the case after it had been closed, ones the government never wanted getting out into the public. “He has long been troubled by disclosures about possible Mafia involvement in the assassination…”
Mob lawyer Frank Ragano wrote that Tampa-based crime boss Santo Trafficante confessed to him in 1987 that he and Carlos Marcello, the mob boss of New Orleans, were responsible for the assassination. According to Ragano, the dying boss uttered the words: “Carlos messed up. We shouldn’t have killed John. We should have killed Bobby.” JFK WAS AN ACCIDENTAL MOB HIT!? That breaks my heart.
Moon landings were faked
The Kennedy Space Center in Florida has an exhibit of the ‘moon’ with the Apollo 11 space shuttle (pictured below). I mean if the moon landings were fake, they could have filmed it right there in the Space Center and no one would be able to tell the difference. Melton says, “There is absolutely no stock for this theory. Even the people who could most politically benefit, the Soviets, did not believe that the landing was faked.”
Clinton Body Count
Bill Clinton wasn’t seen as a ruthless president, but this conspiracy theory completely changes that.
The “Clinton body count” is a list of White House and political associates that died before and during his presidency under mysterious circumstances–there are over 60!
Some of the most famous deaths include Vince Foster, who died in 1993, who was supposedly Hillary’s lover. He was a White House Counsel member and also from the same hometown as Bill. His death was proclaimed a suicide, but everyone knows that’s the CIA’s favorite way to cover it up.
William Colby, director of the CIA who died in 1996, was another notable loss. Colby divulged national secrets, such as the agency’s role in tapping the telephones of Americans, plotting the assassination of Fidel Castro, and using human guinea pigs for mind-control experiments involving LSD. He was replaced by Herbert Walker Bush in 1976, and then, gone…
see also the Bush Body Count
Watch out Putin–you might be next.
Communist fluoride
Speaking of the former Soviet Union, this next theory explains our entire relationship with Russia since the Cold War. They have been poisoning our drinking water with fluoride for 70 years! New York Magazine writes that the communists did this to control the minds of everyone in the United States. The original creation of the chemical has been attributed to scientists in Nazi Germany. Yay for chemistry!
Illuminati
This is the one conspiracy theory that I cannot truly even explain to you. I just don’t really buy it at all. New York magazine writes that the Illuminati is apparently our governing body. Most of our world leaders are really just shape shifting reptiles that are under the control of Lucifer?
Melton explained to me that the Illuminati is like a secret society that runs all the world institutions, such as banks and governments. “It’s almost like the Skull and Bones group at Yale University; it creates an air of mystery that makes everything seem like a bigger deal than it actually is.”
The rest is open to interpretation–the Illuminati could be a thousand different things. All we know for sure is that Beyonce and Queen Elizabeth II are definitely members.
Trying to explain conspiracy theories can be a difficult thing to do because most of them don’t make sense. While interviewing Mr. Melton, he told me a great anecdote that I thought summarized the idea of conspiracy theories very well:
“A paranoid man and his wife decide to stay in a hotel for the night, and the husband is certain that something is watching them in their room. So before they go to bed that night, he searches every niche, every corner and finally finds a little screw underneath the carpet in the middle of the room. Satisfied, he throws it out the window and sleeps, peacefully, through the night. The next morning they are awoken with a knock on the door. It’s the hotel manager. ‘How did you sleep last night?” he asks them. ‘Very well,’ the husband responds. ‘Well I’m glad you did,’ the manager says, ‘because the people below you had a chandelier fall on them while they were sleeping.’
And there you have it–America’s most loved conspiracy theories. Whether you choose to believe them or not, just remember the government is watching. So if I’m not around after the publication of this article, maybe I actually got something right.
Scott Voss • Jan 25, 2016 at 8:29 pm
My biggest concern is when people can no longer rationally discuss matters of science and history because they are so utterly convinced of their theories. I have an acquaintance who belongs to the Flat Earth Society, and it just doesn’t make sense. It worries me that some of these ideas get traction. I have students who believe mermaids are real because they saw a documentary on the Animal Planet, but ignored the “science fiction” disclaimer at the start. Being with these people sometimes reminds of the children in Lord of the Flies who are ruled by superstition, fear and ignorance. Get too many of them believing in the Beastie and before you know it the whole island is burning.
Jordan T. Knobel-Piehl • Jun 7, 2016 at 4:25 pm
^ Absolutely this
Jordan T. Knobel-Piehl • Jan 25, 2016 at 7:28 am
While I don’t think that Bush actually ‘did’ 9/11, it is true that he basically let it happen. There were plenty of warnings beforehand that Al Qaeda was planning an attack, including warnings from the CIA, but Bush apparently thought that Saddam Hussein was a bigger threat.
(Source: nymag.com/daily/intelligencer/2012/09/bush-administration-ignored-september-11-warnings.html )
Anon • Jun 7, 2016 at 1:50 pm
Yes, many people do believe that 9/11 was an inside job yet, we cant blame or government on what happened. You stated before hand that there were warnings, yet you didn’t clarify them. the warnings were acknowledged on August 6th, 2001 stated by the article you sourced from. Those warnings never gave a specific time, date and area. Stating that Bush let this happen is irrelevant, how was he supposed to know that they would attack then and there. It was also not his plan to let this happen. As a president it’s his duty to keep us safe, and he tried to keep us safe. But saying it’s his fault for letting 9/11 happen is out of context.
Jordan T. Knobel-Piehl • Jun 7, 2016 at 4:35 pm
I didn’t mean that it’s his fault, I just meant that he should’ve been more careful. Extra security measures, putting the country on a level of alertness at least one higher than default, especially how he reacted afterwards, invading the wrong country, and, when he found out that he was in the wrong place, staying there and refusing to leave. And that’s only one of his major presidential screwups.
(Read more: http://winningdemocrats.com/historians-have-declared-george-w-bush-to-be-the-worst-president-here-is-why-infographic/ )